Saturday, November 21, 2026Sat, Nov 21

Moon: waxing gibbous, 91% litAurora: quiet

Español

Space, Earth and the natural world, explained.

Bath Study Finds Essential Genes Mutate No Less Than Others

A University of Bath analysis of E. coli and baker's yeast found no sign that essential genes mutate less often, challenging a 1972 evolution hypothesis.

A scientist with blue gloves examines a bacterial culture in a petri dish in a laboratory setting.
Photo: Edward Jenner / Pexels

Genes that cells cannot live without do not mutate any more slowly than other genes, according to a University of Bath study published in PLOS Biology. The result runs against a hypothesis first proposed in 1972, which held that evolution shields a cell’s most important genes from random changes.

Dr. Sofia Radrizzani and Professor Laurence D Hurst of the university’s Centre for Evolution analyzed what they describe as the largest collection of spontaneous mutations assembled to date. The data came from two microbes: the bacterium Escherichia coli and baker’s yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae), a single-celled fungus.

What the protection idea claimed

In the standard picture of evolution, mutations create variation and natural selection decides which variants spread. Darwin’s finches are the usual example. Random mutations alter beak size and shape, and when a food source becomes more plentiful, birds with better-suited beaks survive and breed more often.

The alternative hypothesis says mutation is less random than that. Organisms would have evolved ways to lower mutation rates in critical genes, such as those that copy DNA or run basic cell machinery, while genes where change can help, such as those that confer antibiotic resistance, would mutate more often.

The researchers point to a problem with the logic. Mutations in any single gene are already rare, so cutting the rate further would add only a tiny benefit, which makes it hard for selection to favor such a system.

Ghost mutations and how the team avoided them

Earlier studies may have been misled by a measurement effect. Selection quickly removes harmful mutations from important genes, so a population can look as if those genes rarely mutate when the damaging changes simply vanished before anyone counted them. Hurst calls these “ghost mutations”.

To get around this, the team used mutation accumulation studies, experiments designed to record mutations while limiting the filtering effect of selection. The authors also ran three independent tests for leftover selection bias and report that none found evidence of substantial distortion.

They measured gene importance by looking at experiments in which single genes were deleted. Some genes are indispensable and the cell dies without them. Others can be removed with little or no visible effect. If the protection hypothesis were right, the most essential genes should have shown consistently lower mutation rates. In neither species did they.

The team also tested two other measures: how much protein a gene produces and how strongly selection has shaped the gene over thousands of years. Neither predicted mutation rate. “We found that genes producing more abundant proteins don’t have lower mutation rates,” Radrizzani said.

What does vary mutation rates

Mutation rates are not identical across the genome. The study identified features of genome structure and DNA replication that do matter. Genes copied later during replication, for example, tend to collect mutations more often than genes copied earlier. None of these differences matched a system that specifically protects essential genes.

How sure is this?

The work is a peer-reviewed paper in PLOS Biology (2026, volume 24, issue 11), titled “The importance of genes does not predict their mutation rate” (DOI: 10.1371/journal.pbio.3004089). The conclusions rest on one bacterium and one yeast. The sources do not say whether the same pattern holds in animals, plants or other microbes.

Hurst said the team found no grounds for a shift in paradigm. Radrizzani called the claim of slower mutation in important genes “a triumph of hype over substance” and noted that versions of the suggestion keep resurfacing. A renewed debate over it took place in 2023.

For background on how researchers track change in living populations, see five cases of evolution scientists have watched.

Source: ScienceDaily

Site editor: Nikita Sheikin