Gap in 257 Black Hole Mergers Points to Stars That Never Exploded
Gravitational wave data from 257 black hole mergers suggest many black holes formed in failed supernovas. Here is the evidence and what remains unproven.

Black holes about 10 times the mass of the sun make up 75% of a sample of 257 black hole mergers, and almost none weigh 12 to 16 solar masses, according to a study published Nov. 10 in the journal Physical Review D. The authors say the pattern fits the idea that many of these black holes formed when massive stars collapsed without ever exploding as supernovas.
If that reading holds, a large share of the black holes that astronomers detect colliding came from stars that simply vanished, a kind of death that has strong theoretical support but no direct proof yet.
The usual story of how black holes form
In the standard picture, a massive star runs out of fuel for nuclear fusion and its core collapses. Shock waves from the collapse hit the star’s outer layers and blow them apart in a supernova, while the crushed core becomes a black hole. Theorists have long suspected that some massive stars skip the explosion and fall straight in on themselves. Space.com reports that these “failed supernovas” are well supported in theory, but there is no hard evidence that they happen.
Background on how black holes form and what they are helps explain why the explosion step has been assumed for so long.
How the team read the gravitational waves
The study used data from LIGO (the Laser Interferometer Gravitational-Wave Observatory) and its partner detectors, Virgo in Europe and KAGRA in Japan. These instruments pick up gravitational waves, tiny ripples in space sent out when two black holes spiral together and merge. Since the first detection in 2015, the network has recorded more than 300 black hole collisions.
A team led by Katerina Chatziioannou of the California Institute of Technology (Caltech) looked at the masses of 257 mergers detected over the past 10 years. This is an analysis of observations, not an experiment or a computer model of individual stars.
The mass distribution showed a strong peak at about 10 solar masses. The team expected that peak. They did not expect the shortage of black holes between 12 and 16 solar masses. “We see 10 solar-mass black holes merging all the time,” said team member Isaac Legred of the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign, who asked why ones of around 14 solar masses are so rare.
The researchers also checked how fast the black holes spin. Spin carries clues to how a black hole was born, and the 10-solar-mass group showed its own distinct range of spin speeds. Taken together, the mass peak, the gap above it and the shared spins suggest the group has a common origin, possibly stars that imploded without a supernova.
What is still unproven
The authors describe their result as consistent with failed supernovas, not as proof of them. Legred said more research is needed. He also noted that searching old sky records for massive stars that failed to explode is hard, because such a star leaves only a dark patch where it used to shine.
Chatziioannou said in a statement that the 10-solar-mass black holes “may be a distinct subpopulation” that failed to go supernova. The study does not identify any single star that vanished this way.
Why it matters
Most merging black holes in the universe are about 10 times the sun’s mass, according to Chatziioannou. If most of them came from quiet collapses, then a common path to black hole birth would be one that telescopes cannot see directly, since there is no explosion to observe. Gravitational waves would then be one of the few ways to study it.
Chatziioannou said the results connect gravitational wave data to the underlying physics of stars. Legred said the gap in masses may point to a particular mix of internal physics that produces so many 10-solar-mass black holes, a question the team leaves open for future work.
Source: Space.com



